A software subscription almost always looks cheaper at first: a few dozen dollars per user per month, no project to manage, and you can start tomorrow. Custom software, on the other hand, takes a significant investment before it does anything for you.
Over three or five years, though, the math often flips. Not always. It depends on a few variables you already know.
Add up the total cost
The advertised price of a subscription is only part of what you pay. To compare on equal terms, add up what each option will cost over the same period.
Subscription side: the price per user, times the number of users, for 36 months, plus paid add-ons, integrations and yearly price increases.
Custom side: development, hosting and maintenance over the same period.
A 3-year example
Let’s take a service business that pays $75 per user per month for management software, for 25 users. The price goes up 5% a year, and two integration add-ons cost $3,000 a year.
The amounts in this example are fictitious. They are only meant to illustrate the math and are not a quote from LADEV.
| Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | 3-year total | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Subscription (25 users) | $22,500 | $23,625 | $24,806 | $70,931 |
| Add-ons and integrations | $3,000 | $3,000 | $3,000 | $9,000 |
| Subscription total | $79,931 | |||
| Custom development | $45,000 | $45,000 | ||
| Hosting and maintenance | $6,000 | $6,000 | $6,000 | $18,000 |
| Custom total | $63,000 |
In this case, custom software costs about $17,000 less over three years, and the gap keeps growing after that, since year four only costs maintenance.
One note: to keep the table readable, it leaves out the subscription months you keep paying while the software is being built. In real life, they add to the cost of the custom option in year one.
The tipping point
Run the numbers again with 10 users instead of 25. The subscription drops to about $37,000 over three years, well below the $63,000 for custom software. The subscription wins, by a wide margin.
The variable that matters most is the number of users. The bigger your team, or the faster it grows, the more custom software makes sense. For a small, stable team, a good off-the-shelf tool is often still the best choice.

The hidden costs of subscriptions
- Price increases you don’t control.
- Features locked behind a higher plan, which force the whole team to upgrade.
- Paid integrations to connect the tool to your other software.
- Leaving: getting your data back in a usable format, the day you switch tools, is sometimes harder than expected.
- Lost time when the tool doesn’t fit your process and your employees work around it with Excel files.
The hidden costs of custom software
The other side deserves the same scrutiny.
- Maintenance never stops: security updates, components to replace, fixes.
- New features: once the tool is adopted, your teams will ask for more.
- Vendor lock-in, if the code is poorly documented or you don’t have access to it.
- Time to launch: it takes a few months before the tool is useful, while a subscription works from day one.
When to stick with a subscription
- Your team has few users and isn’t expected to grow much.
- Your process is standard, like accounting or payroll.
- The tool covers most of your needs without workarounds.
- You don’t have time to get involved in a development project right now.
Run the table with your own numbers
Send us your current subscriptions: number of users, prices, add-ons. We’ll run the math over three and five years with your own figures.